No Nut November Rules: Does Edging Count? Does Sex? Answered
The No Nut November rules, settled from the sources: what counts as failing, whether edging, porn and sex count, and why wet dreams and precum don't.
Researchers asked 418 people what the No Nut November rules are for a study published in 2025, and no single answer won a majority. Still, more than three in four named a version where any ejaculation ends the month, so the core rule is no ejaculation from November 1 to November 30.
Wet dreams don’t count. Edging and porn are allowed on paper, and they’re the riskiest things you can do all month. Sex with a partner depends on your version, so pick yours before the 1st.
No Nut November is an internet challenge to get through all of November without ejaculating, and its rules have shifted since the start. The earliest Urban Dictionary definition, from 2011, banned masturbation but said sex with your girlfriend or wife was fine. The subreddit’s 2018 rules made sex a disqualification, birthday sex included. Every answer below is checked against those sources and the 2025 study.
Key takeaways
- The core No Nut November rule is no ejaculation from November 1 to November 30. In a 2025 study, 390 of 418 respondents (93.3%) named a rule that bans ejaculating on your own.
- Wet dreams and precum don’t count. The subreddit’s 2018 rules allowed both.
- Edging and porn don’t break the core rule on paper. The 2018 rules called masturbating without finishing “a very bad and risky method,” and we recommend cutting porn out completely, in November and after it.
- Sex depends on your version. The 2011 original allowed it, and the 2018 subreddit rules count it as a fail if you finish.
- No version has a majority. The top answer, no ejaculation, got 44.5% of respondents, and no sexual activity of any kind got 33.3%.
In this post
- The rules at a glance
- Who wrote the No Nut November rules?
- Does edging count?
- Can you watch porn during No Nut November?
- Does sex count in No Nut November?
- Do wet dreams count?
- The small print
- How to pick your version
- Mistakes that end the month early
The rules at a glance
| Does this break No Nut November? | Answer | Where the answer comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Ejaculating on your own | Yes | 2011 original and 2018 subreddit rules |
| An orgasm without ejaculation | Yes, under the subreddit’s rules | 2018 subreddit rules |
| A wet dream | No | 2018 subreddit rules |
| Precum | No | 2018 subreddit rules |
| Edging | Not on paper. Risky in practice | 2018 subreddit rules |
| Watching porn | Not on paper. The riskiest habit you can keep | 2018 subreddit rules |
| Sex with a partner | Depends on your version | 2011 original vs 2018 rules |
| Your birthday | No exception | 2018 subreddit rules |
| Three strikes or a “coupon” | Not a real rule | 2018 subreddit rules |
Anything stricter than this table is a house rule. We recommend two for everyone, no porn and no edging. Set yours on October 31, while you’re calm, and write them down.
Who wrote the No Nut November rules?
No Nut November has no governing body, so the closest thing to an official rulebook is a post on r/NoNutNovember from November 1, 2018. Even that post rewrote the challenge it inherited.
The earliest Urban Dictionary definition, dated November 3, 2011, describes a challenge in which “an individual must not masturbate for the month of November.” The same entry went on: “You can, however, engage in sexual intercourse with your girlfriend or wife during this time period, if you have one.”
It started spreading as a meme in November 2017, according to Know Your Meme, and a popular image on Twitter that month claimed you got three strikes before you failed. A year later the subreddit’s rules scrapped the strikes, banned sex that ends in orgasm and allowed wet dreams. The post drew 2,600 upvotes and 575 comments. As of October 2026, Reddit shows it as removed, but Know Your Meme kept a copy of the rules.
Then the researchers arrived. In 2025, Melody Garas, Samantha Levang and Caroline Pukall, from the psychology department at Queen’s University in Canada, published what they called “the first investigation of NNN” in The Journal of Sexual Medicine. They recruited people in October 2023, partly through a No Nut November subreddit, and asked what the rules are.
| What the rule is, according to respondents | Share |
|---|---|
| No ejaculation (anything before that is fine, alone or with a partner) | 44.5% |
| No sexual activity of any kind | 33.3% |
| No solo activity (sex with a partner is fine) | 15.6% |
| No partner activity (solo is fine) | 1.9% |
| Something else | 4.8% |
No version won a majority. Whatever someone in the comments calls “the rules,” most of these respondents picked something else.
Look at what the versions share, though. The first two rows, 325 of 418 (77.8%), rule out ejaculating at all, alone or with a partner. Add the third row and 390 of the 418 (93.3%) named a rule that bans ejaculating on your own. It’s a recruited sample rather than a census, so treat the exact split as rough.
Does edging count?
No, not by the letter of the core rule. Edging means getting close and stopping before you finish. The subreddit’s 2018 rules allowed what they called non-ejaculatory masturbation, which covers edging, as long as you never reached orgasm. The same section called it “a very bad and risky method to approaching this challenge.”
Under a November 2025 failure post on r/NoNutNovember, one user replied that “the ground on the edge is all loose and slippery, one misstep and you fall all the way down to rock bottom.”
Every edge bets the month on stopping at the exact moment stopping is hardest, and the next night you make the same bet again. The rule allows it. We’d still count it as a fail in your own version, especially if you’re using November to quit porn.
Can you watch porn during No Nut November?
Technically, yes. The 2018 rules said “You are allowed to watch porn” as long as you don’t climax, and the most popular answer in the 2025 study (no ejaculation, anything before that is fine) leaves porn alone too.
In practice, porn works against the whole challenge, because it winds up the very urge you’ve promised to sit out. “Peeking” is the subreddit’s word for a quick look at porn that’s supposed to stop there. One November 2025 failure post on r/NoNutNovember started with exactly that. Its author wrote, “I decided to ‘reward’ myself by peeking,” and titled the post “I peeked, I failed, I lost gold.”
So cut it out completely and block it before the month starts. On Android, NoBeep blocks the porn sites, words and apps you choose, and one switch, Adult Content Protection, turns on a built-in list of adult sites and keywords. It won’t switch off on impulse, because you have to stop and work through a short pause first.
The blocking happens entirely on your phone. Your keyword list and your browsing never leave it, and we don’t collect any of it. On iPhone, NoBeep walks you through blocking triggers and adult content step by step. For the free tools Android already gives you, such as SafeSearch and Private DNS, see our guide to blocking porn on Android.
Does sex count in No Nut November?
If you finish, yes, under the subreddit’s rules. Sex without finishing sits in the same gray area as edging. The 2011 original allowed sex with a partner, so the real answer is that it depends on your version, and that’s a decision for two people.
In capitals, the 2018 rules said: “SEX IS A DISQUALIFICATION, BIRTHDAY SEX INCLUDED.” One user in that thread asked, “What if my girlfriend and I both want to do no nut November but we still want to have sex?” The author of the rules replied that the rule assumes “you orgasm in the end,” and added: “I don’t recommend it and it’s really risky, but ultimately it’s up to you.”
In the 2025 study, 15.6% of respondents still described the 2011 version, with solo activity off and sex with a partner allowed.
Have the conversation before November 1, because two weeks in, at midnight, is the worst time to negotiate. If you’re both in, the subreddit’s version means neither of you finishes. If it’s only you, the 2011 version is a legitimate way to play, as long as you chose it before the month began.
Do wet dreams count?
No. The 2018 rules said wet dreams “will not be considered a dis qualifier of No Nut November since they are completely unintentional.” A rule about choices can’t cover something that happens while you’re asleep.
The exception is waking up partway and finishing it yourself, because that part was a choice. Why wet dreams get more common on a long streak, and what to do the morning after, is in our guide to wet dreams on semen retention.
The small print
The 2018 rules answered most of the edge cases people still argue about.
- Precum. Doesn’t count: “Pre-cum is allowed since it can occur without orgasm.”
- A dry orgasm. Counts. If your body goes through an orgasm “even without any visible semen it is considered a disqualification.”
- Coupons. The rules called the “One Nut Allowed” coupon a “pagan concept” and declared all coupons “null and void.” As a mercy, anyone who had already cashed one in on the first day could stay in by lasting until December 1.
- Your birthday. No exception, because it “would be an unfair advantage to your fellow brothers who weren’t conceived on Valentines Day.”
- A medical test. The rules don’t cover this one. If a doctor needs a semen sample, give it. We’d call that a medical exception and keep the streak going.
How to pick your version
Choose the version that matches why you’re doing this.
| If you’re doing No Nut November to | Play this version | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Have fun with friends | No ejaculation, no porn | No ejaculation is the most common answer. We recommend adding no porn, because porn shows up in the subreddit’s failure posts |
| Quit porn | No ejaculation, no porn, no edging | Porn and edging are where a lot of Novembers go wrong |
| Do it with a partner | Nobody finishes, or solo is off and sex is fine | Both versions have history, so decide together and early |
| Keep up semen retention | Your usual rules | You already play a stricter version. November just adds company |
Write your version in one line and put it where you’ll see it on November 1. For what each week of the month throws at you, read the No Nut November survival guide.
Mistakes that end the month early
Rule arguments are fun in October. These are what actually cost guys November.
- Writing the rules on November 14. A rule you invent halfway through will bend to fit whatever you want that night.
- Treating “allowed” as “safe.” Edging and porn are legal under the subreddit’s rules, and they’re also how a lot of months end.
- Leaving porn one tap away. “Just peeking” is a plan to fail slowly.
- Skipping the talk with your partner. Two people playing two versions is an argument with a date already set.
- Treating one slip as the end of November. Under the subreddit’s rules, one slip ends the challenge. It doesn’t have to end your month, so read what to do after a failed No Nut November before you need it.
Sources
- Garas, Levang and Pukall, No Nut November, temporary abstinence, and sexual wellbeing, The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 2025
- Urban Dictionary, No Nut November, November 3, 2011, via the Internet Archive
- Know Your Meme, No Nut November / NNN, including the 2018 r/NoNutNovember rules
- r/NoNutNovember, Rules for participating in No Nut November, November 2018
Frequently asked questions
What are the rules of No Nut November?
The core rule is no ejaculation from November 1 to November 30. The subreddit’s 2018 rules add that any orgasm counts as a fail, sex included, while wet dreams and precum don’t. In a 2025 study of 418 people, 44.5% said the rule is no ejaculation, 33.3% said no sexual activity at all and 15.6% said only solo activity is banned.
Does edging count in No Nut November?
Not by the letter of the core rule. Edging stops before ejaculation, and the subreddit’s 2018 rules allowed masturbating without orgasm, which covers it. The same rules called that “a very bad and risky method,” and edging shows up in the subreddit’s failure posts. If you’re using November to quit porn, count edging as a fail.
Does sex with a partner count in No Nut November?
It depends on your version. Under the subreddit’s 2018 rules, sex that ends in orgasm is a disqualification. That includes birthday sex. The original 2011 definition was looser, banning only masturbation and allowing sex with a girlfriend or wife, and 15.6% of respondents in a 2025 study still said partner sex is allowed. Agree on your version together before November 1.
Can you watch porn during No Nut November?
Technically, yes. The subreddit’s 2018 rules allowed porn as long as you didn’t climax. We recommend cutting it out completely anyway, because porn keeps the urge running all month and “peeking” shows up in the subreddit’s failure posts. Block it before November 1.
Do wet dreams count in No Nut November?
No. A wet dream happens while you’re asleep, so it isn’t a choice and it doesn’t reset your streak. The subreddit’s 2018 rules said wet dreams “will not be considered a dis qualifier” because they are “completely unintentional.” There’s one exception. If you wake up partway and finish it yourself, that part is a choice, and it counts.
Does precum count in No Nut November?
No. Precum is a clear fluid released during arousal, before ejaculation, and the subreddit’s 2018 rules allowed it “since it can occur without orgasm.” It doesn’t break your streak. It is a sign of arousal, though, so if it keeps happening, look at what you were doing beforehand. Edging and porn would explain it.
Ready to start?
Reading is the first step.
Day 1 is the next.
NoBeep is the app built for the recovery you just read about. Streak tracker, panic button and a blueprint for rewiring your brain. Free to get started.